2008 WL 907432, *2 (S.D.Ill. Case No. 06-CV-662-JPG, April 2, 2008) The FCA whistleblower moved to amend her complaint. The Defendant, Dr. Nayak, objected, arguing that amendment was futile as the amendment still failed to plead with the particularity required by Fed.R.Civ.P. 9(b). The Court, reviewing the proposed amended complaint,... Continue Reading →Tags: David Honig, False Claims Act, FCA, fraud with particularity, Hall Render, Nayak, Rule 9(b)
496 F.3d 730, (7th Cir. 2007), cert. denied 552 U.S. 1183, 128 S.Ct. 1246, 170 L.Ed.2d 66, 76 USLW 3316, 76 USLW 3437, 76 USLW 3439 (U.S. Feb 19, 2008), overruled on other grounds, Glaser v. Wound Care Consultants, Inc., 570 F.3d 907, 910 (7th Cir. 2009). The Court rules that to... Continue Reading →Tags: claim, False Claims Act, FCA, fraud with particularity, individualized transaction, Rule 9(b)
415 F.3d 601 (7th Cir. 2005) The whistleblower alleged that the Defendants filed a myriad of different “forms, written reports and study results” during the course of a federally-subsidized study. He did not state when the documents were filed, did not specifically identify any of them, and did not allege... Continue Reading →Tags: AIDS Research Alliance-Chicago, False Claims Act, FCA, Gross, relator, whistleblower
The Federal Government has reinforced its expanded theory of false claim liability for quality matters by settling allegations against a hospital that a physician’s lack of qualifications to perform certain surgical procedures should be considered a false claim, regardless of the patient’s outcome. As part of the settlement, the hospital... Continue Reading →Tags: Azmat, Brian Bettner, False Claims Act, Hall Render, James Hogan, peer review, Rogers, Satilla Regional Medical Center
Last month the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) published proposed rules for reporting of overpayments. These proposed rules, if adopted and strictly interpreted, could effectively create a twenty-year statute of limitations under the False Claims Act.... Continue Reading →Tags: 60 day, Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, CFR, CMS, CMS–6037–P, Code of Federal Regulations, False Claims Act, FCA, identification, overpayment, proposed rule, regulation, sixty day, statute of limitations, ten years
February was an interesting month, with one case showing how OIG advisory opinions can be taken too far, another considering fraud under a corporate integrity agreement, and a court applying burden-shifting for the first time at the appellate level in FCA retaliation cases. Cases reviewed from February are: US ex rel.... Continue Reading →Tags: advisory opinion, Aggregate Industries, Bell Constructors, Boggs, Bright Smile, caselaw, False Claims Act, fraud with particularity, Harrington, Klein, Klusmeier, law, legal, Matheny, Medco, OIG, qui tam, relator, retaliation, update, whistleblower
January, 2012, saw two different examples of the Government using the False Claims Act to bring a gun to a knife fight. In the first case the gun won the day. In the second, it backfired. Both cases were brought in the U.S. Court of Federal Claims and in both... Continue Reading →Tags: affirmative defense, Chapman, Court of Claims, estoppel, False Claims Act, FCA, Honeywell, Najjar, Railway Logistics, reverse false claim
What must a successful FCA defendant show to collect attorney’s fees under the Equal Access to Justic Act? Can an error by the government create an FCA violation by a defendant relying upon the government’s acts? Does Vermont Agency of Natural Resources v. US ex rel. Stevens apply to FCA... Continue Reading →Tags: Comstock, EAJA, Equal Access, False Claims Act, FCA, Fox, Huang, immunity, lease, Pecore, person, pro se, qui tam, real party in interest, relator, retaliation, Select Medical, Stevens, Thouvenot, Villaspring, whistleblower, worthless, Wright
Can an incompetent, and ultimately dismissed, False Claims Act Complaint bar a future complaint under the FCA’s “first to file rule?” The Court of Appeals in Washington D.C. answered the question for the first time on November 4, 2011. Can a settlement agreement between an employer and an employee force... Continue Reading →Tags: 2011, AARS, Batiste, Cancio, CDC, Chicago, Compass Medical, D.C., dialysis, District of Columbia, False Claims Act, FCA, Foglia, fraud in the inducement, Glynn, Massachusetts, New Jersey, November, Ohio, qui tam, relator, Renal Ventures, Ruble, Scott, seal, settlement agreement, Skidmore, SLM Corporation, Tampa, whistleblower, Wildhirt
A case based upon FOIA documents may be subject to the public disclosure bar. A difference of scientific judgment does not create the basis for an FCA suit. Whistleblowers who wish to dismiss their suits after the Government refuses intervention may not hide their identity from the defendants, even if... Continue Reading →Tags: Danner, Durham, False Claims Act, FCA, Hill, Matsutani, Prospect Waterproofing, Quality Health Care, quit tam, relator, retaliation, seal, University of Medicine & Dentistry of New Jersey, whistleblower